Home / Coffee Knowledge / Moccamaster KBG 741 Coffee Machine Test – As Good as Its Reputation?
    Filterkaffeemaschinen
    Moccamaster KBG 741 Kaffeemaschine Test – so gut wie der Ruf?

    Moccamaster KBG 741 Coffee Machine Test – As Good as Its Reputation?

    The Moccamaster has an almost legendary reputation. It is valued for its design, craftsmanship, durability, and the quality of the coffee it produces. This made us curious. We subjected the brewer to an intensive test. We tested 40 brews with different coffees, brew ratios, and quantities.

    Our results are considerably more nuanced than the many positive online reviews. But let's take it step by step. As coffee makers, one thing is particularly decisive for us: the quality of the coffee in the cup.

    The following parameters are crucial for this: the temperature of the brewing water, the distribution of the brewing water over the coffee, and the flow rate of the coffee water.

    The choice of coffee and the grind size are important, but cannot be influenced by the machine. Nevertheless, we provide tips for suitable coffees and an appropriate grind size.

    Moccamaster Guide – One Button for Coffee

    Operating the Moccamaster KBG 741 is really as simple as it gets. In this regard, the Moccamaster hardly differs from most other filter coffee machines. Insert a filter, weigh out the coffee, pour water into the permanently mounted water tank, and start with a button press. We wouldn't be coffee makers if we didn't refine these instructions.

    We generally recommend rinsing the paper filter thoroughly with hot water. This reduces the paper taste that would otherwise overpower the coffee later. A positive side effect is that the coffee filter paper then adheres better to the edges of the filter holder. This reduces the likelihood of the paper filter folding inward and water bypassing it. You can't rinse through too much water, but 300 ml is a good amount.

    Next, add the correct amount of ground coffee. The right dosage depends on the desired drink quantity. A good standard value is 60 grams of coffee per liter of water. We discussed this in more detail in an in-depth blog post.

    We initially made two brews. 18 grams of coffee with 300 ml of water, and 60 grams of coffee with 1000 ml of water. We measured out each quantity. We also weighed the water. We started the brew with a button press. We compared these two brews by taste.

    18g and 300 ml vs. 60g and 1000 ml

    In the comparative blind tasting of the two brews, the brew with the larger volume performed significantly better. Better meant that the coffee tasted more balanced and homogeneous. It was also noticeably stronger, meaning more pronounced in flavor. The 18g/300ml brew had a slightly unpleasant acidity on one hand and lacked the complexity and expected flavor notes of the coffee on the other.

    We adjusted the grind size of the 18g/300ml slightly finer and made additional brews. However, the result did not improve significantly. As you can see in Table 1, the strength in particular—that is, the concentration of dissolved coffee particles—was relatively low at just over 1.0% on average. This value can be measured with a refractometer. A desirable result is around 1.1–1.5% strength (TDS = Total Dissolved Solids), with the rest of the beverage being water. Finer grind sizes typically increase resistance in the coffee, leading to slower drainage of the brewing water and thus more intensive extraction. However, we were unable to achieve significantly stronger brews with the coffee and water quantities used by refining the grind size.

    Grams mg Water Output Strength Extraction Brew Time Drip Cycle
    18 11 300 250 1.06% 14.72% 02:02 01:13
    18 11 300 264 1.04% 15.25% 02:04 01:08
    18 11 300 264 1.02% 14.96% 02:00 01:09
    18 11 300 260 0.98% 14.16% 01:55 01:08
    18 11 300 255 1.08% 15.30% 02:05 01:10

    Table 1.

    The target extraction rate is 18–22%. Extraction refers to the proportions of the coffee bean that are removed from it. When higher extractions are achieved, the strength in the cup is also more pronounced. These two values are therefore dependent on each other (see also blog post on Strength and Extraction).

    Table 2 shows the results of the 60g/1000ml brew. Here we achieved stronger results with the same brew ratio. The strength averages above 1.2% TDS, which is within the target range. Accordingly, extraction is within the target range in two of the five brews. In theory, we could have increased extraction with a finer grind size. However, the drainage in the filter was too slow and the water level was at maximum. A finer grind size would have caused the filter to overflow.

    Grams mg Water Output Strength Extraction Brew Time Drip Cycle
    60 12 1000 887 1.21% 17.89% 04:33 03:32
    60 12 1000 882 1.30% 19.11% 04:40 03:42
    60 12 1000 896 1.12% 16.73% 04:21 03:27
    60 12 1000 880 1.22% 17.89% 04:36 03:40
    60 12 1000 886 1.23% 18.16% 04:33 03:33

    Table 2.

    The comparison of the brews shows that the Moccamaster's extraction yield is better with larger brewing volumes. This is primarily due to the distribution of water over the coffee bed. With larger brewing volumes, the brewing water better reaches all coffee particles and washes them out more effectively. This is mainly due to the design of the brew head.

    Buy Moccamaster KBG

    The following specialty retailers* carry the Moccamaster KBG and we recommend purchasing from these businesses.

    Switzerland: [Partner links] Adrianos

    * We search for specialty partners we know do good work and offer good service. We maintain close contact with these retailers. These are affiliate links. If you order through this link, it costs you nothing more, but we receive a small commission that we invest in new testing equipment.

    The Well-Intentioned Brew Head

    Almost all classical filter coffee machines have the problem that the brewing water continuously drips onto the same spot in the coffee bed—usually right in the center. At this spot, the coffee grounds are heavily stirred with each drop and bubble and thoroughly extracted by the constant influx of water. Meanwhile, many other coffee particles at the edge of the coffee bed settle in comfortably and watch the extraction party in the center.

    brew head 1024x350

    It doesn't take much to brew good filter coffee—except for even extraction. This is achieved when as many coffee particles as possible are in contact with water equally intensively and for the same length of time. Those who brew by hand practice exactly this technique. Moistening everything evenly and stirring it, that's what gives delicious coffee.

    Moccamaster understood the principle and developed a rod-style brew head with 9 holes. This is supposed to distribute the brewing water onto the coffee bed. Supposed to, because at least with the device we tested, it doesn't work. The water flows into the brew rod and drips out largely from the front holes. Ultimately, however, where the water exits is of secondary importance, since the water below the brew head combines into a single, connected stream.

    We changed the angle of the brew rod to rule out that it might be due to a slanted table or something similar, but we repeatedly arrived at the same result.

    The consequence is that the brewing water is predominantly extracted in the center and a larger portion of the coffee bed is not evenly saturated. With larger water quantities—which is why the brew with 60g/1000ml was better—this plays a secondary role because a water layer forms on top of the coffee grounds anyway. But even in this case, the extraction is not even.

    This malfunction did surprise us. The brew head with multiple outlets shows the right principle. However, the distribution of water is not pronounced enough to provide a significant improvement.

    brews 1024x350

    Better Brews Through Stirring

    When the brew head doesn't do its job, the tricks of hand brewing come into play. Simply stirring the coffee after around 20–30 seconds of brew time leads to noticeably better brewing results. If you repeat the stirring once all the water has been added, the brewing results are significantly more homogeneous and more delicious.

    Grams mg Water Output Strength Extraction Brew Time
    60 12 1000 885 1.36% 20.06% 05:10
    60 12 1000 881 1.31% 19.24% 04:58
    60 12 1000 887 1.32% 19.51% 05:00
    60 12 1000 884 1.35% 19.89% 05:02
    60 12 1000 889 1.29% 19.11% 04:57

    Table 3

    Table 3 also shows a noticeably longer brew time. This occurs because now the entire coffee creates resistance. By stirring at the end of brewing, rotation is deliberately created, which picks up the coffee particles at the edge in a vortex and moves them along throughout a larger portion of the brew.

    Moccamaster Brew Temperature

    Generally, the brew temperature should be constant. Exceptions prove the rule. There are coffees that simply taste best when brewed at 80 degrees. In my filter coffee courses, I almost always run the test: participants brew the same coffee at 50, 60, 70, 80, 90, and 100 degrees. There's a clear trend that the coffee tastes best when brewed at 90 degrees. Repeatedly, individual coffees also perform well at other temperatures. A brew temperature of 92–94 degrees is the most popular brewing temperature across all brews.

    Temperature Moccamaster

    The Moccamaster brews very consistently—but slightly too hot in temperature. It reaches temperature incredibly quickly. Even on the first brew of the day, it's ready to brew after not even 20 seconds and the first water drops drip onto the coffee.

    We measured the temperature directly at the water outlet. The first flush of water dripped onto the coffee at a water temperature of 60 degrees. However, this was only a few milliliters, which was likely cooled by heat exchange with the metal brew rod. Subsequently, the Moccamaster brews very precisely and consistently at 98–99 degrees at the outlet throughout the entire brew cycle. The impact temperature is hardly lower since the brew head is close to the coffee. In other words: the brew temperature is very high—rather too high for many coffees. These high temperatures tend to enhance the bitterness in coffee.

    98 degrees brew temperature is certainly an option for very clear and lightly roasted coffees that naturally contain little bitterness and are very transparent. For the vast majority of coffees, however, this temperature is too high. It becomes particularly critical for coffees that are not specialty coffees and are roasted darker. Here, a brew temperature of around 90 degrees or less would be the best choice.

    Pulse Brewing vs. Continuous Brewing and Bloom

    The Moccamaster brews continuously from the first to the last drop. From brew start, water is added in a steady stream. We tested the flow with Black Mirror's interesting scale. The scale actually consists of two scales. It measures on one hand the weight of water being poured onto the filter and on the other hand the amount of brewed coffee already in the pot.

    black mirror2

    black mirror

    Continuous brewing is well suited to deliver consistent results from extraction to extraction. Pulse brews, also called pulse brewing, add water in bursts. An initial burst serves as a bloom. During this, only a small amount of water is added. The CO2 created during roasting can escape. CO2 is on one hand not pleasant to taste and on the other hand its release causes stirring in the coffee bed. This so-called blooming makes sense especially with darker roasts, since they have significantly more CO2 bound in them.

    Another reason we recommend using the Moccamaster mainly for lighter roasts.

    The following graphic shows two brews that we captured with the Black Mirror app. On the left was brewed with the Moccamaster, on the right by hand.

    Conclusion and Outlook Moccamaster KBG 741

    We have tested the Moccamaster thoroughly. The Moccamaster is the third filter coffee machine we are testing in a series of coffee machines. Our background is manual brewing. The author was Swiss Brewers Cup Champion (Filter Coffee Champion) and multiple runner-up. The standard for good filter coffee is high—but not so difficult to achieve. As mentioned at the beginning, only a few basic parameters need to be met.

    We look at automatic filter coffee machines because we expect for the future that an automatic machine can better deliver consistency across many sequential brews—while maintaining quality.

    The Moccamaster is not yet that machine. The Moccamaster delivers satisfactory to good results compared to hand-brewed filter coffee with light roasts and poor to satisfactory results with dark roasts.

    Its temperature is very consistent—but unfortunately too high. The water distribution is well-conceived but doesn't function sufficiently in practice. The machine's greatest asset is its excellent build quality and 5-year warranty.

    These tests were conducted with our test unit, which we purchased, like all our other test units.

      Comments

      Welche Maschine sollen wir noch testen?

      Espressomaschine oder Mühle: Sag uns, was als Nächstes auf unseren Testtisch soll. Wir lesen jeden Wunsch.

      Deine E-Mail nutzen wir nur für Rückfragen zu deinem Wunsch. Den Newsletter bekommst du nur, wenn du ihn ankreuzt und bestätigst. Datenschutzerklärung